Jackson Township, PA - Mitchell Ternay, 38, and Noah Benner, 26, Killed in Route 328 Crash

Jackson Township, PA – Mitchell Ternay, 38, and Noah Benner, 26, Killed in Route 328 Crash

Jackson township pa car crash

Jackson Township, PA (November 7, 2026) – Two Tioga County men were killed in a single-vehicle crash on Route 328 west of Millerton on November 7, according to Pennsylvania State Police.

State police at Mansfield identified the men as Mitchell R. Ternay, 38, who was driving, and Noah C. Benner, 26, a passenger. Troopers said the crash involved driving under the influence and that toxicology testing is still pending.

According to the crash synopsis released by state police, a 2007 Honda Accord was traveling north on Route 328 at a high rate of speed. Troopers said the car passed the intersection with Alder Run Road and came up on a right-left S-bend.

State police said the car went off the right side of the road while taking the second left curve and traveled onto the grass shoulder. Troopers said the vehicle re-entered the roadway, braked, spun counter-clockwise about 90 degrees, and struck a tree.

The car split into three sections, according to state police. Troopers said the engine and firewall came to rest 58 feet northeast of the tree, the front half about 68 feet east of the tree, and the rear half approximately 191 feet northeast of the tree.

State police said both men were wearing seat belts at the time of the crash. The exact speed at which the crash occurred is unknown, according to troopers.

This is a developing story. Details may change as the investigation continues.

What to Do After a Fatal Car Crash in PA

  • Request the crash report and the name of the investigating unit from the state police barracks at Mansfield. The report number is needed for nearly everything that follows.
  • Ask that the vehicle not be released, repaired, or salvaged yet. The wreck itself is physical evidence, and tow yards move quickly.
  • Route insurance calls to one family member or to an attorney, so nobody gives a recorded statement in the first weeks of grief.
  • Order several certified copies of the death certificate. Insurers, banks and employers each keep one.
  • Keep funeral invoices, medical bills, and records of missed work together from the start, rather than reconstructing them months later.
  • Hold off on public posts about the crash. Insurers review social media during a claim.

DUI Liability and a Passenger’s Claim After a Fatal Pennsylvania Crash

A passenger’s claim stands on its own. When state police report that impairment was involved, the passenger’s family is not shut out by that finding, because the passenger did nothing to cause the crash.

Pennsylvania treats the civil claim and the criminal investigation as separate tracks. That matters here, since no criminal case can proceed against a driver who died. The civil claim usually begins with the driver’s own liability coverage, and where that coverage is thin, the next place to look is uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on policies in the passenger’s household.

Toxicology results in Pennsylvania commonly take months. A family does not have to wait for them to start preserving evidence, because the vehicle, the roadway and the curve itself all change long before a lab report is issued.

  • Who may be liable: the driver’s estate and his insurer, and in some cases a bar or restaurant that served a visibly intoxicated driver under Pennsylvania’s dram shop law.
  • What the evidence has to show: the state police reconstruction, the crash synopsis, toxicology results, the vehicle inspection, and the tire and road evidence at the bend.
  • If fault is shared: Pennsylvania applies modified comparative negligence, and recovery is barred only when the injured person is more than 50 percent at fault (42 Pa.C.S. 7102).
  • The deadlines that matter: wrongful death and survival claims generally must be filed within two years (42 Pa.C.S. 5524), which puts that date at November 7, 2028. If a condition of the state road turns out to be part of what happened, written notice to the responsible government unit is due within six months (42 Pa.C.S. 5522), which falls on May 7, 2027.

Contact Our Pennsylvania Car Accident Attorneys

Scartelli Olszewski, P.C. has represented injured people and grieving families across Northeastern and Northern Pennsylvania since 2001. Melissa A. Scartelli, the firm’s founder and president, is a Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate certified by the National Board of Trial Advocacy. The attorneys here carry more than 100 years of combined trial experience.

Our Pennsylvania car accident lawyer team handles fatal highway crashes, impaired driving cases, and passenger claims throughout the northern tier. Our firm’s results include a $650,000 car accident settlement, and its attorneys are Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum members.

On a case built like this one, the early work decides the outcome. We send preservation letters so the vehicle is not scrapped, obtain the full state police reconstruction file, retain reconstruction and toxicology experts, and take the adjusters off a family’s hands.

Families in Tioga County are usually choosing a firm for the first time after a fatal crash, and these are the facts worth weighing:

  • $10,000,000 record verdict in Luzerne County
  • 100+ years of combined trial experience, with hundreds of jury trials tried
  • Led by Melissa A. Scartelli, Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate by the National Board of Trial Advocacy
  • Former District Attorney and Court of Common Pleas judge Peter Paul Olszewski, Jr. on the team
  • Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum members
  • 4.7 Google rating across 39 client reviews, with no disciplinary history for any attorney
  • Free consultation and no fee unless we win
  • $650,000 car accident settlement

Our Scranton office at 411 Jefferson Avenue is the closest to the northern tier. Call (570) 346-2600, come see us there, or send the details through our contact form, and we will call you back.

Do You Have A Case? Call Us At 570-346-2600

Disclaimer: The information in this news post is based on reliable sources, including local news reports, statements from the Pennsylvania State Police, and online resources. The image used is for illustration only and does not depict the incident. Nothing in this post is intended as an accusation of wrongdoing against any person or business; all incidents described are subject to ongoing investigation. This post is not a solicitation and is not legal or medical advice. If you locate inaccurate information or would like a post removed, contact our team and we will address it promptly.