Testimonials

My husband was an attorney in Honesdale and when he needed a really sharp lawyer he called on this firm. When my son-in-law had a vehicular accident that wasn’t his fault I remember my husband telling me about Melissa and her office We contacted her and were impressed by the caring and time they gave us. My husband has passed and I am sure he was sitting on my shoulder being happy with our choice. No question was too small or unimportant to any of the staff

Attorney Olszewski was very professional, direct, and the best! Looking out for your rights!

I had an exceptional experience working with Attorney Scartelli and the entire team at Scartelli Olszewski. From our very first meeting, it was clear that I was in the hands of highly skilled professionals who truly care about their clients. Attorney Scartelli’s attention to detail, compassion, and unwavering dedication to justice gave me peace of mind during a very stressful time. The firm kept me informed every step of the way, patiently answered all my questions, and made sure I felt supported throughout the process. Their legal knowledge and strategic approach were instrumental in achieving a favorable outcome in my case. If you're looking for a legal team that combines experience, integrity, and personalized service, I wholeheartedly recommend Scartelli Olszewski. They go above and beyond, and I am truly grateful for everything they’ve done for me. Thank you Melissa, Kristin, and Rachel!

Was wrongly accused of a very serious Felony 3 account and hired Peter Paul Olszewski. The entire firm of Scartelli Olszewski worked tirelessly to have the Pike County Assistant District Attorney as well as the District Magistrate Judge Dismiss the charges! Very pleased with the outcome of this Law Firm and recommend this Law Firm.

Scartelli Olsheski, P.C, Attorneys at Law and entire staff are experts in their field of practice. They could win a Gold medal for their Professionalism, and Kindness . Everyone we dealt with in their office: Attorney Melissa Scartelli, Annmarie, Patrick and Tony were very efficient and courteous. My husband and I were in a car accident in February 2024, when a drunk driver rear-ended us. The drunk driver actually fled the scene/drove away, and went down the road causing another car accident. We were injured. Melissa Scartelli,Esq. and fine staff helped us expertly. We highly recommend this law practice, and are grateful for their outstanding representation in this matter.

Dealing with the attorneys over at Scartelli Olszewski was nothing short of satisfactory. Through the entire 4 year process we had, I was constantly kept updated and cared for. More than doing their job, they truly care for their clients which I felt off the first meeting with Melissa. Both my family and I are forever thankful for them!

My experience was exceptionally excellent. I was kept updated with everything. There was no ambiguity with any proceedings. I would recommend Rachel as a lawyer to anyone, including family and friends.

Rachel was awesome with my case and very helpful with my case! I would recommend this law firm! They truly care! Thank you! They were as timely as can be expected as well!

Peter Paul Olszewski, Jr., Esq. was excellent to work with. We found him professional and courteous. He didn’t let the issues that arose linger, he was on top of them. He was calm and helpful to us, but bold when representing us. Peter Paul was persistent and diligent in helping us to get a favorable outcome. He gave good counsel. He was available at all hours, got back to us right away whether he was on vacation or doing his own activities, no matter the circumstances. He was always excited and encouraging about any positive advancements that were made in our case. He conferred with his partner (and wife) for strategies and counsel. He looked for ways to keep us out of litigation and to keep our expenses to a minimum. He always had our welfare in mind. He asked the right questions and did the right research. Overall, a very positive experience. Highly recommended.

I recommend Peter and Melissa to anyone who needs a car accident lawyer. After being hit head on by a car driving in my lane, I didn't know where to turn. After a referral from St. Thomas More Church, I turned over all the information to Peter and Melissa. They were awesome and treated my case as if I was part of their family. They fought hard for everything I was entitled to from the driver of the vehicle and my own insurance company as the driver had very limited insurance. Thank you, Peter and Melissa, and all the fine employees of Scartelli Olszewski, P.C.

I called Attorney Olszewski regarding a potential case. He lead me step by step through the process. He was beyond professional. I would highly recommend Attorney Olszewski to anyone.

Excellent!!!!!! Absolutely the best!!! Rachel Olszewski is professional, courteous, and caring. Her family is second to none.

I had the pleasure of having Attorney Rachel Olszewski on my case. She was great. She always, always, always, kept me in the loop as to what was going on, and consulted me on everything before any decisions were made. She always asked me how I was feeling and explained everything in layman’s terms. Anyone who I spoke to in the office when I called was always professional and courteous. I was lucky enough to have my case move rather quickly. I would recommend this law office to anyone looking for kindness, compassion, and caring as they deal with a tough part of their lives. The law office of Scartelli Olszewski, P.C. will get the job done!

The very first time my husband and I walked into Scartelli Olszewski, we felt at home and like part of the family. Melissa and her team are very professional, respectful, compassionate, hard-working, and extremely knowledgeable. Melissa and her team worked hard to give us our life back and for that, we will be forever grateful.

I don't think I could have picked a better team to represent my case. My situation was unique and extremely complicated but it was handled with the utmost care and professionalism. The firm's strong and organized representation ultimately brought great results and helped reconcile a tragic event.

Great law firm. I was in a car accident and Melissa showed great skill and professionalism in helping me. I felt cared for and appreciated. They helped me along the way and did not make me feel like just a number.

Melissa and her team were exactly what I looked for in a law firm. Professional, great response time, and communicative. I would definitely recommend them to anyone that was looking!

Melissa Scartelli and her entire team did an exceptional job with our very difficult case. They are driven, competent, timely, experienced, and compassionate. Their experts were exceptional. Melissa’s research and deposition skills are absolutely outstanding. Her entire staff worked diligently under her direction and delivered amazing results. The whole process exceeded our expectations. I would highly, highly recommend their law firm.

Highly recommend this firm. Each and every case is given 100%.

Had a very positive experience with this law firm! They go above and beyond to build a strong case for their clients and make you feel as if you're more than just a client, but also a friend. They are still very helpful to this day!

I highly recommend Scartelli Olszewski, P.C.! Committed to professionalism, dedicated to your needs, and swift to get justice.

Class act!!!

I have no complaints. They were respectful, courteous, and on top of everything, I highly recommend using them.

They were compassionate and understanding, great people.

So happy about a case Attorney Olszewski just won for us. His office staff is very accommodating and Attorney Olszewski returns calls promptly. He did so much research and really knew what he was talking about. I was very impressed. Hope I never need him again but if I do, there will be no hesitation in calling him.

They settled a difficult case in our favor and achieved a better settlement than we imagined. The staff was very professional and compassionate and they kept us appraised of developments from start to finish. Highly recommended!

Melissa and the crew at Scartelli Olszewski have helped me navigate the complicated legal landscape on several occasions. Responsive, competent, compassionate, and genuine are just a few words that come to mind. Highly recommend you put this firm on your call list!

With all we had to medically and emotionally deal with, we know that the legal and financial was taken care of by Scartelli Olszewski, P.C. Thank you, Scartelli Olszewski, P.C. and staff for your expertise and support, for communicating each step of the process and being successful with what you told us.

We worked with Melissa on two occasions. Very professional and dedicated. Highly recommend.

I have every confidence in this legal team to provide accurate and thorough advice and representation. Melissa, Pete, and their colleagues are genuine in their willingness to help clients and above all are consummate professionals.

Professional and courteous staff treated me with respect and care. Highly recommend!!

Great, great law firm, very professional. They give 100+, their staff is A+, you will feel like they are family. Highly recommended. Love them all.

Helped my family tremendously years ago and always made us feel like a top priority and that they cared. Very passionate about helping us and sympathetic towards what we were going through. Great people in the office who are always willing to answer questions. NEVER a regretful thought about working with this law firm. Highly recommend!

Melissa Scartelli is one of the top Pennsylvania lawyers. Very proud to know her and work together. She is professional and caring.

A quality law firm – they take cases they know they can win. They have a very professional staff and will fight for your rights. Highly recommended!!!!